If you’re searching for the heart of Greece, NY’s dining scene, look no further than Paddy Hill. Nestled along Dewey Avenue and Latta Road, this neighborhood may be small, but its food offerings pack a delicious punch. Whether you’re a lifelong local or a hungry first-time visitor, Paddy Hill is full of dining surprises — from classic Italian bakeries to American diners, Mediterranean grills, and cozy cafés. Ready for a tour? Let’s dig in!
Warm Welcomes and Homestyle Classics: Dewey Avenue’s Mainstays
Dewey Avenue serves as the spine of Paddy Hill’s food scene, boasting eateries where tradition and hospitality shine.
- Blue Ridge Grill
At the corner of Dewey and Latta, Blue Ridge Grill is a longtime Greece favorite. With a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere, Blue Ridge is the spot for hearty American fare done right. From all-day breakfasts (the cinnamon swirl French toast is a must-try) to plentiful lunch and dinner plates — burgers, wraps, and daily specials — the menu is large, portions are generous, and prices remain reasonable (most dishes under $15). Locals rave about the Friday fish fry and legendary homemade soups.
- Carbone’s Pizzeria
Just down Dewey, Carbone’s Pizzeria is a fast-casual spot that punches way above its weight in flavor. Known for its classic New York-style pizzas, garlicky wings, and overstuffed subs, Carbone’s delivers affordable, satisfying eats (slices start around $3; most entrees $10-$15). Grab a pie to share or stop in for lunchtime pizza by the slice.
- Dewey’s Delights Food Truck
In warmer months, Dewey’s Delights food truck pops up near Dewey and English Road. This mobile spot specializes in creative comfort foods — think loaded mac & cheese bowls, specialty grilled cheese sandwiches, and inventive fries. Prices are friendly ($5-$12), and everything is made fresh to order. It’s a local secret for quick, flavorful night bites!
Paddy Hill’s International Flavor
Beyond American classics, Paddy Hill’s diverse residents bring global tastes to the table.
- Basha Mediterranean Eatery
On Latta Road just west of Dewey, Basha offers a taste of the Mediterranean from Greece to Lebanon. Their chicken shawarma wraps, house-made falafel, and fresh tabbouleh are local legends. Try the mixed grill platter for a sampling feast, all at wallet-friendly prices ($7-$14 for most entrees). The vibe is warm and casual, making it perfect for a laid-back lunch.
- Martino’s Italian Bakery & Deli
Hidden just off Dewey Avenue on Baird Road, Martino’s is a family-owned institution. Walk in and be greeted by the heavenly scent of fresh bread and sweet pastries. The hot subs and cold cut sandwiches (many under $12) make a perfect midday meal, but don’t miss homemade cannoli, Italian cookies, or their signature tomato pie. Locals say it’s just like nonna used to make!
Cozy Coffee Corners and Bakeries
Need a sweet treat or a caffeine fix? Paddy Hill has you covered.
- Colie’s Café
A hidden gem tucked into the Galleria Plaza (Latta at Long Pond), Colie’s Café is a favorite hangout for breaks and brunches. The menu features locally roasted coffee, flavor-packed paninis, gourmet salads, and a bakery case full of treats. Must-tries include the breakfast burrito and any seasonal muffin. The laid-back vibe, free Wi-Fi, and affordable pricing ($5-$12) make this a great remote-work or study spot.
- Village Bakery & Café
While the flagship is in neighboring Pittsford, Village Bakery’s Greece location is just a stone’s throw away at Latta and Long Pond. Their artisan breads, pastries, and specialty lattes are beloved by locals. Grab a scone or croissant for breakfast or stop in for a midday pick-me-up. The prices are reasonable ($2-$6 for most bakery items).
Noteworthy Hidden Gems
Some culinary treasures in Paddy Hill are so tucked away you might miss them — unless you know where to look!
- El Latino Restaurant
Located on Dewey near Maiden Lane, El Latino serves up authentic Dominican and Puerto Rican dishes in a casual, friendly setting. Try the mofongo, roast pork, or their daily lunch special (usually under $10). Rice, beans, and plantains abound, and their homemade hot sauces pack a satisfying punch. Portions are plentiful and packed with flavor.
- Sue’s Northgate Family Restaurant
Behind a nondescript strip mall exterior on Northgate Plaza, Sue’s is a breakfast secret spot. With loyal regulars lining up on weekends, this old-school diner excels at eggs benedict, stuffed pancakes, and breakfast skillets that don’t skimp on size or flavor. The menu also covers classic lunches and early dinners, with most dishes priced under $12. It’s the kind of place where the staff remembers your coffee order.
The Paddy Hill Foodie Experience
What truly sets Paddy Hill apart is its mix of old and new — where decades-old diners share the block with modern coffee shops, and family-run bakeries sit side-by-side with multicultural eateries. This neighborhood’s food scene radiates community warmth. Many owners live locally and greet regulars by name, making everyone feel like a neighbor.
The best way to experience Paddy Hill’s food scene? Go hungry, go often, and don’t be afraid to try something new. Explore the main drag down Dewey, branch out onto Latta and Long Pond, and keep an eye on seasonal food trucks circling the area.
Final Bites: Pro Tips and Don’t-Miss Dishes
- For a comforting bite on a chilly day, try Blue Ridge Grill’s homemade soups or the breakfast skillet at Sue’s Northgate.
- Feeding a crowd? Martino’s tomato pie and Carbone’s party pizzas are always a hit.
- For an Instagram-worthy brunch, Colie’s Café has you covered — their lattes are super photogenic.
- Curious about Paddy Hill’s flavors? Basha’s sampler platters and El Latino’s weekend specials offer a taste of something unique.
From longstanding favorites to creative new finds, Paddy Hill proves that big flavor comes in local packages. Next time you’re in Greece, NY, explore this neighborhood’s culinary gems — you just might find your next favorite spot.